11/14/26

Christians Can Speak Their Values in Public (Part 2)

Thinking more about Christians Can Speak Their Values in Public

The USA dates its founding to July 4, 1776, the day the Declaration of Independence was adopted. The 1813 letter attributed to John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, dated June 28, 1813, 37 years later.

Founding milestones

  • 1776: Declaration of Independence.
  • 1783: Treaty of Paris. Britain recognizes U.S. independence.
  • 1787–1789: The Constitution is written and ratified, and the new government begins with George Washington as president.

The 1813 letter

Adams wrote that the principles the Founders used to win independence were “the general principles of Christianity,” joined with the principles of English and American liberty. He explained that these were the common ground that held a mix of religious groups together during the Revolution.

What was going on in 1813

  • The country was at war. The War of 1812 with Britain was in full swing. U.S. troops burned York (today’s Toronto) in April. Oliver Hazard Perry won the Battle of Lake Erie in September. Tecumseh was killed at the Battle of the Thames in October.
  • James Madison had just started his second term as president.
  • An old friendship was back. Adams and Jefferson had been bitter political rivals. Their mutual friend Dr. Benjamin Rush got them writing to each other again in 1812. Rush died in April 1813, just weeks before this letter. Their letters went on until both men died on the same day, July 4, 1826.
  • Adams was grieving. He was 77 and retired in Quincy, Massachusetts. His daughter Nabby was dying of cancer at home that summer, and she died in August 1813.
  • Europe was at war too. Napoleon’s empire was falling apart, and he lost the Battle of Leipzig that October.

So Adams wasn’t looking back on the founding in calm times. The young nation was fighting Britain again, and he was looking back on what had held it together the first time.

What’s driving the debate now

  • The 250th anniversary. The founding is being argued over again. The debate over the Founders’ religious intentions has heated up as the 250th anniversary of the Declaration approached this year.
  • Politics. PRRI polling finds a fairly linear link between favorable views of Trump and Christian nationalist beliefs. It isn’t only a white phenomenon either: a majority of Hispanic Protestants also hold Christian nationalist beliefs. newrepublicnewrepublic
  • January 6. Commentators across the spectrum agree that January 6 is the main reason the term “Christian nationalism” entered the mainstream. theweek
  • Culture-war flashpoints. Examples include schools, abortion, immigration, and laws like the one in Texas that could require Bible study and prayer in schools. wfdd
  • Some people now claim the label. Stephen Wolfe’s The Case for Christian Nationalism (2022) and Doug Wilson’s circle embraced the term on purpose. In August, Wilson, Al Mohler, and others debated it in Moscow, Idaho, and Wilson said the goal was to cut through the “definitional pandemonium” around the term. favs

The defenders’ case 

  • The term was built as a weapon. Historian Mark David Hall says the phrase was coined by critics in 2006 and has mostly been used to condemn conservative Christians who bring their faith into the public square. ccu
  • There’s a double standard. Hall argues the critics treat Christians fighting abortion or defending religious liberty as scary Christian nationalists, but praise Christians driven by faith to pursue civil rights laws. ccu
  • The research is stacked. Defenders call the main surveys seriously flawed and ambiguous. wng
  • The threat is overblown. Hall says the critics greatly exaggerate the dangers. posthillpress
  • It’s really aimed at evangelicals. One writer warns that the label may be a code word for “evangelicalism.” patheos

The critics’ case 

  • Patriotism versus nationalism. Critics say the issue isn’t faith in public life. It’s merging faith with state power. Brandon Haan of the Christian Reformed Church put it this way: patriotism is a good thing, but it can easily slip into becoming the ultimate thing. thebanner
  • It harms the church. Christianity Today’s Paul D. Miller argues that even the moderate form is theologically and politically damaging, while the extremist form is dangerous in more direct ways. christianitytoday
  • It’s broad. The campaign called Christians Against Christian Nationalism, run by a Baptist religious-liberty group, has over 40,000 signers, many from churches that once saw themselves as apolitical. forward


No comments: