11/16/26

Spotter, Not Substitute: A Christian Way to Think About AI (str.org)

I recently sat in on a talk for Christian parents about AI (Grace.church Reality Technology Parent Session hosted by str.org). It was followed by a parent panel. I left with a lot to think about.

The big idea: Your worth does not come from what you can do. It comes from bearing God's image. And getting the right answer is not the same as growing wise.

I think that is exactly right. I also think parts of the talk went further than the evidence can carry. Here is what I took away.


What the talk got right

  • Dignity is a gift, not a grade. Genesis 1:27 says, "So God created human beings in his own image." That is true before we produce anything. A machine that writes faster than us does not make us worth less.
  • Answers can skip the learning. The speaker called this a "counterfeit mind." If AI hands you the answer, you may never build the skill.
  • Fake attention can crowd out real people. A chatbot can sound caring. But it cannot love you back. The talk called this a "counterfeit person."
  • Technology cannot save us. Living longer is not the same as resurrection. Only Christ offers that.
  • Parents need more than filters. This came from the panel, and it may be the most useful point of the night. Controls can block things. They cannot teach judgment. Kids need ongoing, honest talks with their parents.


The best picture: AI as a spotter

Think about the gym. If someone lifts the weights for you, you get no stronger. A good spotter does not lift for you. They stand close, keep you safe, and help you finish.

That is how AI should work when the goal is growth.

But not every hard thing is a holy thing. If I am trying to grow a skill, handing it off defeats the point. If I am fixing formatting on a slide, letting AI help frees me for work that matters more.

Some struggle shapes us. Some is just busywork.


Where I would push back

An apology with help is not always fake. The talk used an example of a student named Tyler who used AI to write an apology. His words sounded smooth, but nothing changed. That is a real problem.

Still, someone who struggles with words might use AI to say something they truly mean. The better question is simple:

Does the person mean it, own it, and live it out?

Mistakes are not the same as lies. When AI gets something wrong, that is an error. A lie needs a choice to deceive.

Online friends can be real friends. The screen is just the way you talk. What matters is whether a real person is on the other end.

A few loud voices are not the whole field. Some tech leaders do dream about living forever through machines. That does not mean everyone building AI shares that goal.

Christian content needs checking too. If we teach kids to test viral videos, that has to include the ones we agree with.


Keep Scripture in its lane

The talk leaned on several passages. Some fit well. Some need care.

  • Genesis 1:27 strongly supports human dignity.
  • Psalm 115:8 warns that we become like what we trust. To apply it to AI, we have to show real misplaced trust, not just use.
  • Genesis 11 warns against pride at Babel. It does not say building things is wrong.
  • Isaiah 29:13-14 was used near the end as a promise of revival for students. Read in context, it is a warning. God overturns human wisdom when worship is empty. (Read it here)

Also worth saying: the talk mixed three kinds of claims. Some were about the Bible. Some were about research. Some were about big questions like what makes a person. All three matter. But one cannot stand in for the other.


What the research actually says

Lots of teens use AI companions. A national survey from Common Sense Media found that 72% of teens ages 13 to 17 had tried one. About a third of those users had talked to an AI about something important instead of a person. (Survey results)

But most still pick real friends. The same survey found 80% of users spent more time with friends than with AI. Common Sense still recommends against AI companions for kids under 18, because of safety risks. (Risk assessment)

The spotter idea holds up. In one study, high school math students who used open-ended AI did better while practicing. Later, without it, they did 17% worse than students who never had it. Students who used an AI tutor built to guide, not give answers, did not show that drop. (Study)

Bottom line: The problem is not AI. The problem is letting AI do the growing for us.


Four questions for families

Before and after you use AI for something that matters, ask:

  1. Purpose: What am I trying to do? Learn something? Finish a chore? Say something? Feel better?
  2. Practice: What skill do I need to keep? Could I do this without AI?
  3. Presence: Who needs me, not a machine? Apologies, hard talks, caring for someone, and promises belong to people.
  4. Proof: How will I check it? Go to the source. Admit what you don't know.

Why this matters for my own work

I build ministry tools that use AI, including Tri-Bible.ai and Rooted. This talk sharpened a rule I want to live by:

AI can help prepare and reflect. People stay responsible for understanding Scripture, sharing their story, approving translations, and caring for one another.

Here is one idea I want to test. Have students try an answer first. Then let AI coach them. Then have them explain it on their own. My guess is they will remember more than students who just get the answer. We should measure what they remember, not just how sure they feel.


The takeaway

We do not need to fear AI. We also should not hand it the parts of life God meant us to carry.

Let it spot you. Don't let it lift for you.

No comments: